The Widening CEO-to-Worker Pay Gap: Risks for Business Leaders and Boards

The Widening Wage Gap Between Workers and CEOs

The debate over CEO pay vs. worker wages has intensified as new data shows that executive compensation at America’s largest companies continues to grow far faster than average employee earnings. According to a CEOWORLD magazine poll in April, 80% of workers believe their CEOs are overpaid.

Now, an analysis from the CEO Policy Institute and UGGP News confirms that perception: the pay gap between CEOs and workers at the lowest-paying S&P 500 companies has widened by nearly 13% over the last five years. CEO pay is rising more than twice as fast as the median worker’s wages in these firms.

The Starbucks Example

One striking case is Starbucks, where CEO Brian Niccol reportedly earned $95.8 million last year. By contrast, the average Starbucks worker made just $14,674. That’s a pay ratio that stretches into thousands to one, raising tough questions for shareholders, boards, and regulators about sustainability and fairness.

Structural Inequality in Leadership

The report also highlights how these disparities reinforce broader gender and racial inequities. Women and people of color disproportionately occupy low-wage jobs, while they remain underrepresented in senior leadership roles.

Among the “Low-Wage 100”—the S&P 500 companies with the lowest median worker pay—only eight have female CEOs, and just one has a Black CEO. The implication: pay gaps are not just financial but structural, reinforcing barriers to equitable leadership.

Why the Gap Matters

For CEOs and boards, widening wage disparities carry risks beyond reputational damage:

• Employee Morale and Retention
  When workers perceive executive pay as excessive, it undermines engagement and productivity.
• Investor Pressure
  ESG-minded investors are beginning to scrutinize pay equity as part of corporate governance. Excessive CEO pay packages may draw pushback from institutional shareholders.
• Regulatory Risk
  Governments in the U.S. and Europe are increasingly interested in pay transparency and fairness. New rules could force disclosure and invite public scrutiny.
• Market Reputation
  Companies seen as exploitative risk alienating consumers, particularly younger demographics who value social responsibility.

Key Numbers / Facts Box – CEO Pay vs. Worker Wages

• 80% of workers believe CEOs are overpaid (CEOWORLD poll, 2024).
• 13% increase in CEO-worker pay gap at lowest-paying S&P 500 firms over five years.
• 2x faster growth: CEO pay vs. average worker pay in those companies.
• $95.8M: Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol’s annual pay.
• $14,674: Median Starbucks worker pay.
• 8 out of 100 low-wage S&P companies have female CEOs.
• 1 out of 100 has a Black CEO.

Executive Takeaway

For business leaders, the widening pay gap is not just a moral or political talking point—it is a strategic risk. Boards must reassess compensation structures to ensure executive pay growth is tied to long-term performance, not short-term optics.

CEOs need to communicate clearly how pay packages align with shareholder value creation and employee opportunity. C-Suite leaders must confront the equity issue, ensuring pathways to leadership for women and minorities, not just higher pay ratios.

The bottom line: excessive disparity erodes trust. In a market where talent, reputation, and investor confidence drive value, ignoring wage gaps could cost more than any executive paycheck is worth.

Have you read?
The Citizenship by Investment (CBI) Index evaluates the performance of the 11 nations currently offering operational Citizenship By Investment (CBI) programs: St Kitts and Nevis (Saint Kitts and Nevis), Dominica, Grenada, Saint Lucia (St. Lucia), Antigua & Barbuda, Nauru, Vanuatu, Türkiye (Turkey), São Tomé and Príncipe, Jordan, and Egypt.